In the course of the movie you see the fat kid wearing a flannel (plaid) shirt. After the skinny guy gets taken a bundle of sticks are found tied with the shirt the fat kid was wearing. What happened did the witch go in the tent and rip his shirt?
No, the "fat kid" is Mike, not Josh. Josh is the one that looks more like a hippie.
By the way, is anyone else getting sick of this spell-check or is it just me?
The "fat kid" is Mike and he did not get taken, it was Josh, who was very skinny and looks like a hippy who was taken. About the shirt, lots of flannel shirts look alike and I've seen in the movie that Josh had one around his waist a couple times and he might have brought one with him in his pack or something. It was Joshes shirt.