If the year the movies take place in are the same as the years they come out the ages are wrong. Toy Story 3 (2010) Andy was going to collage at 18 years old . If you're 18 in 2010 you were born in 1993. The first toy story came out in 1995 , Andy was portrayed much older than 2 years old. And if Molly was a baby in 1995 she would be in early high school by 2010 . But in the third Toy Story Molly was a pree - teen . And in Toy Story 2(1999) Molly was a toddler . It's 4 years from 1995 from 1999 she'd be 4 . And notice how Andy's mother never aged