Movies | TV | Books | Quotes Easter Eggs
[Slipups.com Logo] The Slip-Up ArchiveTM
SLIPUPS.COM
Home > Books > E - H > Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone/Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Bloopers Add a Slip-Up
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone/Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone - Sorting Mistake
This is a little mild, but, anyway, in the sorting hat scene, J.K. Rowling writes there's only three left, but there are four people to go.
Be the first to post pictures of this Slip-Up!
Rated 3.5/10 (675 ratings) Your opinion?
Special Requirements: None, just the book
Contributed By: Freezy on 12-27-1999 and Reviewed By: Webmaster
If something isn't right, please Correct this Slip-Up

Comments:
g.willikers writes:
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone American version Paperback page 122 "And now there were only three people left to be sorted. 'Thomas, Dean,' a Black boy even taller than Ron, joined Harry at the Gryffindor table." Rowling should have switched the order of those two sentences in order for the whole instance to be logical. I think she meant that Dean Thomas had already been sorted as he ambled over to the Gryffindors and she noted the number of students left.
45 of 52 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
HeRmIoNe GrAnGeR writes:
Oh my gosh! You're right. Here are the ones that get sorted after the book says there are three more left: Thomas, Dean Turpin, Lisa Weasley, Ron Zabini, Blaise
37 of 41 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
Pencil Mug Beast writes:
I have the British and American versions. In the British version, there are only three people to go. But it was changed entirely for Americans as evidenced by the title changed. Dean Thomas is the one not mentioned in the British version. It also says nothing as to his race. But Dean Thomas is definitely a first year. Basically what we have here is overly politically correct publishers trying to fix a mistake, but they didn't do it properly.
20 of 25 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
Helena writes:
I have been working on a comparison of the British and American texts. I've only got it about half done yet, but you can see the difference between the two versions of the sorting scene if you scroll down to chapter six: http://helenajole.freeservers.com/home/Harry.html
12 of 13 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
Starkiss831 writes:
I think they meant 3 more until Ron was sorted.
11 of 21 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
Stella writes:
I actually read one place that this mistake is ONLY in the American version, and that one of the characters (I think Dean Thomas) doesn't even APPEAR in the other editions.
5 of 10 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
Zordy writes:
They meant that there were only 3 people left until Ron was sorted. Harry wanted him in Gryffindor, so....
7 of 14 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
aznskaterchick writes:
It's all good in the Canadian version!
11 of 23 found this helpful. Did you? Yes
the voice of pain writes:
Even if Dean Thomas is not mentioned in the British version, at the sorting ceremony, that does not mean he never got sorted. He still had to be sorted even if his name was not called in the text.
2 of 9 found this helpful. Did you? Yes

Want more Slip-Ups?
More Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone/Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Bloopers
Top 25 Bloopers in E - H
All E - H Bloopers
Top 25 Bloopers
Newest Bloopers
Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone/Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone Easter Eggs